Skip to content

Comparison

CrestCast vs Plum

Plum is an automated saver with a spending tracker attached: it reads your transactions, works out what you can spare and moves it into savings, and shows you what you spent. CrestCast is a household forecast: it shows where the money is heading and when cash runs short. That is why CrestCast does not connect to your bank: it is not analysing the past, you type the plan.

Comparison pointCrestCastPlum
Kind of appForecasting app. It shows where your money is heading, ten years outAutomated saver with a spending tracker attached. It has no feature it calls a budget
What it tells youWhere your money is heading, and when cash first runs shortWhat you spent, by category, and what it has moved into savings for you
Which way it looksForwards, ten years, day by dayBackwards, over your transactions, to work out what you can spare. Plum Plan, an AI-built plan, puts a number and a timeline on a goal you set
Bank connectionNone. It is not analysing the past, so it needs no feed: you type the plan, or import a CSVYes, read-only, through Open Banking. Everything it sets aside is worked out from the feed
SavingSet a minimum to hold in the current account and an order for where anything above it goesAutomated rules: an amount Plum calculates you can spare, round-ups to the nearest pound, a weekly or payday deposit, and challenges on the paid tiers
SpendingNot categorised. You enter the bills and living costs in the planSpend Tracker sorts transactions into 18 fixed categories and compares this month with previous ones. Every category on Boost and Max, the top two below that
Net worthProjected forward year by year, includedNot described on withplum.com or in its help centre
ScenariosSave versions of the plan and compare two side by sidePlum Plan, free, suggests a plan for one goal as a number and a timeline. Its site calls the projections illustrative and not guaranteed
HouseholdJoint, personal and household views, one price for the householdNothing on its Plum Plan page describes a joint or household plan
Price30 days free, no card. Then £5.99 a month or £59.99 a year, for you or the whole household.Basic is free. Plus £3.99/mo, Boost £7.99/mo, Max £14.99/mo, monthly only, first month free. Users who joined before 07/07/2025 stay on Pro £2.99, Ultra £4.99, Premium £9.99

Prices and features correct as at 15/10/2026. From Plum's subscriptions and Plum Plan pages and its help centre. Two sets of Plum plans run at once; the cell says which a new sign-up sees. Plans change, so check its site before you pay.

Plum is a trademark of its owner; this comparison is independent and is not affiliated with or endorsed by Plum.

A budget is a plan for money you have not spent yet

Plum's engine works backwards by design. In its own words it connects to your bank account, analyses your transactions, identifies your regular income, rent, bills and daily spending, and from those works out each day what can be put aside without affecting your daily life. The output is a transfer, made for you, every four or five working days. The Spend Tracker beside it sorts what you spent into eighteen categories and compares this month with previous months. Neither of them is a budget, and Plum does not call either one a budget.

What Plum is good at is taking the decision out of saving. It works out the amount from the feed, so nobody has to remember to move money, and round-ups, payday rules and challenges add to the pot automatically. Investing sits in the same app. For someone whose difficulty is putting money aside at all, that is the strongest case for it, and it is a job CrestCast does not do.

A household's questions mostly cannot be answered from what it spent. Whether the mortgage is still affordable when the fix ends. What one of you going part time does to the next five years. When the car finance is gone and what that frees up. Those are about money that has not moved yet, and a feed of money that has cannot see them. CrestCast starts from what is coming, builds the next ten years from it day by day, and shows where the money is heading and the month cash first runs short.

Plum does look forward once, in Plum Plan, which it calls a personalised AI roadmap to financial goals. You set a goal, retirement among them, and it puts a number and a timeline on it. It is a goal projection, which Plum's page calls illustrative. It does not say what your current account holds next March. The fuller argument, with every UK app placed on its rung, is on budgeting app, spending tracker or forecast.

What a household forecast looks like

Scroll to pan. Tap Close or press Escape.

Cash balance by day for November 2026, Real terms off. Green bars ease down through the month, then step up on the 27th and stay higher to the 30th
Cash balance by day, with the pay landing on the 27th as a step. Step month by month into 2027 and beyond. Plum reads this month's balance to decide what to move; this shows every month to come.

Scroll to pan. Tap Close or press Escape.

CrestCast net worth by year for the sample household, Combined view, on Annual with the chart on Balance, Milestones off and Real terms off. The header gives net worth and the biggest movement, both at 31/10/2036. Under the heading net worth by year, green bars climb year by year from Tdy to the end of the ten-year forecast, then a hint to tap a bar to see it in the statement below and a legend for positive net worth.
Net worth by year out to 2036, projected rather than recorded. Plum Plan puts a number and a timeline on one goal; this is the whole household, every day.

Figures shown are the sample profile, not a real household.

Where CrestCast is different

CrestCast is built from the figures you choose to enter, so nothing reads your accounts and the model holds exactly what you chose. Here is why I built it that way.

CrestCast works out what the current account needs to hold, puts an order on where anything above that goes, and shows what that does to your cash and your net worth ten years out, for the whole household. If a decision is coming that the past cannot answer, that is the question a household forecast is built for.

Who each suits

CrestCast suits you if the question is where your money is heading: a bigger house in two years, one income for a while, a debt you want gone by a date, two incomes that need to be looked at as one household. It lets you test a decision before you make it, across your cash, your income and your net worth at once. Plum suits you if the question is how to save without thinking about it: the spare money found and moved for you, purchases rounded up into a pot, and a tracker to see where the rest went.

A couple looking at one set of finances together will find the household half on CrestCast for couples.

Free routes cover part of the same ground: the spending view in your bank's own app, a spreadsheet you keep yourself, and the budget planner from MoneyHelper, the free guidance service backed by government (checked 22/11/2026).

Common questions

›Is Plum a budgeting app?

Plum does not call itself one, and it has no feature it calls a budget. Its own description is that it connects to your bank account, analyses your transactions, works out each day what can be put aside without affecting your daily life, and moves that amount into your Plum account. That is an automated saver. A Spend Tracker sits beside it, sorting what you spent into categories and comparing this month with previous months. The forward-looking feature is Plum Plan, which Plum describes as a personalised AI roadmap to financial goals: you set a goal, retirement among them, and it puts a number and a timeline on it. In the terms this site uses, that makes Plum an automated saver with a spending tracker beside it.

›What is the difference between a spending tracker and a forecast?

A spending tracker reads your bank feed and tells you where the money went: categories, this month against last, a report you look at after the fact. A forecast shows where the money is heading and when cash runs short, which means it has to know what is coming: the fix ending in March, the car finance finishing in 2028, one salary dropping for a year. A plan for money you have not spent yet cannot be built from money you already have. CrestCast builds that plan ten years out, day by day. Plum reads what you spent and decides what to set aside from it.

›Does CrestCast connect to my bank?

No, and the reason follows from the split rather than excusing it. Plum needs a bank connection because everything it does starts from your transactions: it reads them to find what you can spare. CrestCast is not reading what you spent. The figures a forecast runs on are not in a statement: the pay rise you have been promised, the nursery fees that start in September, the house you mean to buy in two years. So you describe the plan: in plain English to the AI assistant, which takes under an hour the first time, on the forms yourself, or by handing it a CSV your bank exported and letting it pick out the payments that repeat. No credential is shared, and the model holds exactly what you decided.

›What does Plum do that CrestCast does not?

Everything on the saving and investing side. Plum connects to your accounts through Open Banking, calculates what you can spare and moves it for you, rounds purchases up to the nearest pound and saves the difference, runs weekly, payday and challenge deposits, categorises your spending into a tracker with month-on-month comparison, and lets you invest from the same app. Plum Plan, which is free, builds an AI plan for a goal such as retirement. CrestCast does none of that: it moves no money, holds no money, and does not do retirement planning. If the job is saving without having to think about it, Plum is the better choice.

›How much does Plum cost?

Checked on 15/10/2026 against Plum's own subscriptions page: a UK user signing up now sees Basic free, then Plus at £3.99 a month, Boost at £7.99 and Max at £14.99, monthly only, with the first month of a paid tier free. Anyone who joined before 07/07/2025 stays on the four classic plans, Basic free, Pro £2.99, Ultra £4.99 and Premium £9.99, which Plum's help centre says it still offers. The Spend Tracker shows every category on Boost and Max and the top two on Basic and Plus, and four of the saving rules need a paid tier. CrestCast: 30 days free, no card. Then £5.99 a month or £59.99 a year, for you or the whole household.

›Can I use Plum and CrestCast together?

Yes, and they fit well: Plum to move the spare money into savings without deciding each time, CrestCast to decide how much spare there should be and where it goes once the current account has what it needs. Nothing needs integrating and no data passes between them. The forecast improves the saver too, because a minimum to hold in the current account is the same figure Plum's calculation estimates from the feed.

Other comparisons

This is not advice

This comparison is independent and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Plum or Plum Fintech Ltd. Details about Plum are drawn from withplum.com and its help centre, checked on 15/10/2026, and may since have changed. Nothing here is financial advice.

Plum decides what to set aside. CrestCast shows where your money is heading.

Both incomes, the bills, the mortgage and the children in one forecast, ten years out, so the decisions that cannot be undone stop being guesses.

30 days free, no card. Then £5.99 a month or £59.99 a year, for you or the whole household.